Newsletter; October 1997, Vol. 1
| Developing a Fraud and Abuse Program -
Outline Develop - Implement - Evaluate With the governments increased vigilance in combating healthcare fraud, many organizations are making the implementation of a voluntary compliance program a high priority. The following outline will help you if you are considering such a move, or will serve as a review if you have implemented this type of program. DEVELOPMENT Appoint Someone in Charge Designate a chief compliance officer or other appropriate high-level corporate official who is then charged with the responsibility of operating the compliance program. They may need to be oriented to the information flow which already exists, the quality control measures, and the scope of the mandatory education programs and reporting forms already in place. Create a Plan This will be similar to your current safety or infection control plan but will be tailored to the laws of fraud and abuse. It must include standards of conduct for employees, and ensure that areas such as ethical billing practice are included. In addition to your main plan there should be sub-plans for areas such as the laboratory and their unique approach to compliance. If you are JCAHO accredited, you must have a Code of Ethics. The problem is, most codes are in name only. Go back and review yours against the requirements of HCFA who insist that a code must be established and adhered to. Review the section on organizational ethics in JCAHOs chapter on leadership. Some care needs to be taken in developing a plan. Often an administrator such as the CFO mandates that something must be done. Usually this "knee-jerk" reaction is inadequate resulting in a focus on only one process such as upcoding. They make an attempt, the system fails and they look for a better way. After a few tries it occurs to them that this is a "team project" or "similar to quality improvement", the right people become involved, a team is formed and progress is made. A facilitator, trained in statistical tools and group dynamics, usually manages the team. They are usually a staff person from the quality improvement office who will often provide training and support for these positions. Because of the accountability built into the federal law, each step of the compliance process must be measured. While all managers have been responsible for quality, risk and resource management their new responsibilities need to be clearly outlined and prioritized for them. The compliance planning law clearly states that every individual is responsible. Involve the Key PlayersMany of the key players are already in place with systems up and ready to actively assist with the program. These are systems people, such as QM, UM, Case Managers and Risk Managers, to name a few. They are well versed in developing processes, and ensuring that they merge and end when appropriate. They can be instrumental in developing interfaces of processes which have historically never been together, For example, the MD who writes the orders and the clerk who processes the patient when they arrive for the test. The QM Office will usually be the first one to remember that there needs to be data supplied to validate where to begin the improvement process and documentation as evidence of compliance. Once the compliance plan is drafted, an assessment must follow which identifies which component of the compliance system needs fixing first. This is an area where data is essential. The QM Department can support two of the main features of the improvement process:
Develop Policies and Procedures Policies and procedures will need to be developed which promote the facilities commitment to compliance and that address specific areas of potential fraud, such as billing, marketing and claims processing. IMPLEMENTATION Education and Training Programs Education and training programs will need to be developed and offered to all employees, subcontractors and vendors in order for you to comply with your plan and code of ethics. Education will need to be ongoing; when the program is installed, for new employee orientation, and as a mandatory yearly inservice. Everyone needs to know what ethics violations are and the method of reporting them. In addition to the general education program, there will need to be specific programs for core areas. For example, educational training in "Little Known Facts of Payment for all areas that post charges. Even with a computer program which catches the same patient using services within 72 hours and preventing duplication of billing, if the charges are delayed in posting, the computer is bypassed and multiple billing errors will occur. Develop a Meaningful Reporting System The Quality Management Department is usually the group who pulls all the measures together and reports them in an understandable format for the CEO and administration. Otherwise each of the departments involved will be reporting just one measure from their own perspective. For example, the MD who orders a test, the clerk who follows through with the order in the lab or in x-ray, and the clerk in the billing department who makes up the bill without an ICD-9 code for medical necessity. This is an information overload. The data must be managed, collected and investigated prior to its being delivered to the CEO. This is systems management. Develop a Code of Improper and Illegal Activities This should include the use of disciplinary action against employees who have violated internal compliance policies or applicable laws, or who have engaged in wrongdoing. Policies need to be in place for addressing the non-employment or retention of sanctioned individuals. For example, accepting gifts, or taking kickbacks for referrals. Install a Hotline This will need to be developed and maintained along with procedures to protect the anonymity of complainants. Involve the Corporate Attorney The attorney overseeing the organizations compliance progress will need to be involved for the same reasons peer review information goes to the medical staff, it protects it from disclosure. Re-examine Medical Record Systems The requirements applicable to record creation and retention will need to be reviewed. Investigate all Problems Immediately Develop a sense of urgency and investigate and remediate all identified systemic and personnel problems immediately. EVALUATION Monitoring Techniques The evaluation phase focuses on how all the measures come together and are reported to the CEO. No one department can provide this, it must be a central service. The compliance officer may actually have their own staff. However, to bypass the existing systems in place in the QA department would be a gross misuse of funds and an extremely redundant system. Utilize audits and/or other evaluation techniques to monitor compliance and ensure a reduction in identified problem areas. For example, components of this program could be to perform routine data collection and analysis of patient bills. This is really a quality control activity. But it is very likely that data analysis will indicate an opportunity to improve the way charges are sent, billing is handled, and fraud alerts are transmitted throughout the organization and elsewhere. Include the Program in Performance Appraisals Supervisors are required to promote the program and adhere to compliance requirements as an element in performance appraisals. The compliance program includes a requirement for the discipline of supervisors who fail to detect an ethics violation in their subordinates. As you will surely have already noted in developing any major "Plan", the process is never finished. Reviewing and updating the Plan is an ongoing process as regulations change, departments update their systems and reporting processes. It is a never ending cycle. Other information Swain & Associates offers workshops detailing the Fraud and Abuse issue. For more information call 1-800-843-6449 or E-mail us at Info@SnAConsulting.com. |